The tragic sinking of the British-flagged superyacht Bayesian off the coast of Sicily has left many questions unanswered as search and recovery operations continue. The yacht, a 56-meter luxury vessel built by the renowned Italian shipyard Perini Navi in 2008, sank early Monday in a violent storm while moored about a kilometer offshore. The storm, believed to have included a waterspout—a tornado-like phenomenon over water—struck the Bayesian with devastating force, leading to the vessel's rapid submersion.
Rescue efforts have been ongoing since the incident, with fifteen people, including the wife of British tech magnate Mike Lynch, successfully rescued by a nearby sailboat. Tragically, the bodies of five passengers have been recovered from the wreckage, with one person still missing as divers continue their search. The first body, that of the ship's chef Recaldo Thomas, was found on Monday. Thomas, originally from Canada but having lived in Antigua since his early 20s, was one of the confirmed victims.
The loss of life and the suddenness of the sinking have raised critical questions about the circumstances leading to the disaster. Despite the violent weather, a nearby sailboat, the Sir Robert Baden Powell, suffered only minimal damage and was able to rescue survivors, leading to intense scrutiny of what might have caused the Bayesian to go down so quickly. Giovanni Costantino, head of The Italian Sea Group, which owns Perini Navi, suggested that human error could have played a role in the disaster. He referenced AIS (Automatic Identification System) data indicating that the Bayesian took on water for four minutes before a gust of wind flipped it over, causing it to continue taking on water until it sank within 16 minutes.
Speculation has also centered on the yacht's design, particularly whether its keel, possibly retractable to allow access to shallower ports, might have been up at the time of the incident. This could have reduced the yacht's stability, making it more susceptible to capsizing in extreme weather conditions. Jean-Baptiste Souppez, a fellow of the Royal Institute of Naval Architects, highlighted the potential implications of a lifting keel in reducing stability, which could have made the vessel easier to roll over on its side during the storm.
The captain of the rescue sailboat noted that his own vessel sustained only minor damage, such as the breaking of a sun awning frame, despite encountering hurricane-strength winds that he estimated reached a force of 12 on the Beaufort scale. He suggested that the Bayesian, with its towering 75-meter mast, might not have fared better at sea, where stability issues could have been exacerbated.
The ongoing underwater search has been challenging and perilous. Divers are working in difficult conditions, including limited visibility and the need to navigate through debris from the wreckage. The depth of the wreck, at around 50 meters, requires special precautions to avoid decompression sickness, with divers limited to short, 12-minute intervals underwater. The operation, involving 27 divers, is reminiscent of the recovery efforts after the 2012 Costa Concordia disaster, earning the Porticello wreck the nickname "little Concordia" among the rescue teams.
As the investigation by the Termini Imerese Public Prosecutor’s Office progresses, officials are gathering evidence to determine the exact cause of the sinking. The lack of formal suspects and the complexities of the situation leave many questions open, including the role of possible human error, the impact of the storm, and the structural integrity of the yacht.
For the families of the victims and the survivors, the search for answers continues, with the hope that the investigation will bring clarity and accountability to this maritime tragedy. The loss of the Bayesian and the lives aboard serves as a somber reminder of the unpredictable and often unforgiving nature of the sea.
Â
