Review of "Manorathangal": Kamal Haasan's anthology is beautiful but sluggish at times


"Manorathangal," available on ZEE5 Global, is an anthology that introduces viewers to the profound world of MT Vasudevan Nair, one of the most revered writers in the Malayalam literary and film industry. Presented by Kamal Haasan, who shares a long-standing connection with Nair's work, the anthology consists of nine stories that delve into the intricate layers of human emotions and relationships. The series is a tribute to Nair's ability to create simple yet deeply impactful narratives where the protagonists navigate emotional conflicts without the typical dichotomy of heroes and villains.

The anthology features an ensemble of some of the most celebrated actors from the Malayalam film industry, including Mammootty, Mohanlal, Fahadh Faasil, Asif Ali, Parvathy Thiruvothu, and Aparna Balamurali. What stands out in "Manorathangal" is the way these actors, known for their star power, shed their larger-than-life personas to bring to life the nuanced, everyday characters that are central to Nair's storytelling. In these stories, the characters are not defined by grandeur or extraordinary circumstances but by the quiet, often painful, struggles of their lives. They are individuals wrestling with their decisions, confronting unforeseen situations, and undergoing a process of learning and unlearning.

However, the anthology demands a certain level of patience from its viewers. These are not fast-paced, high-stakes dramas but rather slow-burn narratives that invite the audience to immerse themselves fully in the characters' emotional journeys. The stories take their time to unfold, allowing the emotions to grow and resonate deeply. The more one invests in the viewing experience, the more one can appreciate the emotional depth that Nair and his characters offer.

Among the nine stories, three particularly stand out for their ability to engage and move the audience without relying heavily on long, silent scenes that demand interpretation. One of the most notable episodes is "Kazhcha" (Vision), directed by Shyamaprasad and starring Parvathy Thiruvothu. In this story, Parvathy delivers a career-defining performance as Sudha, a talented woman who is deeply passionate about music but is trapped in a loveless and abusive marriage. When Sudha decides to return to her hometown, she faces harsh judgment for her choices as a separated woman. Parvathy's portrayal of a woman standing against patriarchy, yet doing so with a quiet, dignified simplicity, is both powerful and poignant.

Another standout episode is "Kadugannava: Oru Yathra Kurippu" (Kadugannava: A Travel Note), directed by Ranjith and starring Mammootty. In this story, Mammootty plays Venugopal, a journalist who returns to his village in Sri Lanka to reconnect with his step-sister, Leela. Mammootty sheds his superstar image to embody a man who is nostalgic for his past and yearns to recapture the essence of his childhood. The episode is marked by a bittersweet tone, especially in the final scene where Venu's long-awaited meeting with his sister leaves him with a melancholic realization that not all reunions bring closure.

"Manorathangal" also features "Sherlock," directed by Mahesh Narayanan, with Fahadh Faasil in the lead. In this episode, Fahadh plays Balu, a man who moves to Canada in search of a better life but is caught in a web of inner conflict and cultural dislocation. The story encapsulates Nair's recurring themes of identity crisis, emotional battles, and self-reflection. Fahadh's performance is a masterclass in capturing the subtle nuances of a character who feels trapped between his past and his present, making "Sherlock" one of the most memorable episodes in the anthology.

While these episodes shine, not all of the stories in "Manorathangal" hit the mark. Two episodes directed by Priyadarshan, particularly "Olavum Theeravum" (Ripples and the River Bank) starring Mohanlal as Vappootty, struggle with coherent storytelling. The story of unrequited love between Vappootty and his friend's sister, Nabeesu, feels outdated and lacks the emotional resonance needed to make it compelling. Despite the stunning cinematography by Santosh Sivan, which turns each frame into a piece of visual poetry, the episode falls short of delivering a timeless love story. Similarly, other episodes like "Kadalkkaattu" (Sea Breeze) by Rathish Ambat, "Abhyam Theedi Veendum" (Once Again, In Search of Refuge) by Santosh Sivan, and "Vilpana" (The Sale) by Aswathy Nair, though visually appealing, fail to fully capture the emotional depth and creative genius of Nair's writing.

In conclusion, "Manorathangal" is not a typical anthology that offers quick entertainment. It is a deeply introspective series that requires viewers to engage thoughtfully with the stories it presents. The anthology is a celebration of MT Vasudevan Nair's legacy, bringing to life the simplicity and complexity of village life in Kerala and the emotional landscapes of its inhabitants. It is an invitation to reflect on the essence of human relationships and to consider whether our own lives are as wholesome and fulfilling as we desire them to be. For those willing to invest the time and attention, "Manorathangal" offers a rich, rewarding experience that lingers long after the final episode ends.


 

buttons=(Accept !) days=(20)

Our website uses cookies to enhance your experience. Learn More
Accept !