In his address at the United Nations General Assembly, French President Emmanuel Macron put forth a compelling case for significant reform within the United Nations Security Council (UNSC), emphasizing the urgent need for a more efficient and inclusive body. Macron firmly supported India's candidacy for permanent membership, arguing that the council must expand to include not only India but also Brazil, Germany, and Japan, alongside two African nations to enhance the representation from the continent.Â
"Let's make the UN more efficient," Macron stated emphatically. "We need to make it more representative, and that's why France is in favor of the Security Council being expanded." His remarks are part of a larger international movement advocating for a restructured UNSC, which is currently dominated by just five permanent members: the United States, China, Russia, France, and the United Kingdom. These nations hold significant sway over global security matters, but many argue that their dominance does not accurately reflect the geopolitical landscape of today. While countries like the United States and France have voiced strong support for India’s inclusion in this exclusive club, China's persistent opposition poses a significant hurdle in this endeavor.
The momentum for reform was further bolstered during the recent Quad Leaders' Summit, hosted by US President Joe Biden in Wilmington, Delaware. Leaders from the United States, India, Australia, and Japan reiterated their collective commitment to a comprehensive overhaul of the United Nations, particularly stressing the need for the UNSC to evolve in a manner that includes more countries and reflects the diversity of the international community. The joint statement issued after the summit highlighted the importance of expanding the UNSC and ensuring that it can adequately represent a wider range of nations and perspectives.
Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi has been particularly vocal about the issues surrounding the UNSC's geographic representation. He has pointedly questioned how the council can claim legitimacy in its role as a primary organ of a global body while excluding entire continents, such as Africa and Latin America, from meaningful participation. "How can we talk of it as a primary organ of a global body when entire continents of Africa and Latin America are ignored?" Modi has asked. "How can it claim to speak for the world when its most populous country and its largest democracy is not a permanent member?" His statements resonate with a growing number of countries advocating for a more equitable governance structure at the global level.
Moreover, the UNSC currently also includes non-permanent members, who are elected for two-year terms. These non-permanent members have a role in shaping the agenda but lack the veto power that their permanent counterparts possess. India's relationship with the UNSC is well-established, having served as a non-permanent member eight times in the past, with its most recent term occurring from 2021 to 2022. This extensive experience reinforces India’s argument for a permanent seat, as it seeks to play a more decisive role in global security matters.
The ongoing push for reform within the UNSC is not merely about increasing the number of permanent members; it is fundamentally about creating a more balanced and representative global governance system that reflects the realities of the 21st century. As nations across the globe increasingly call for a fairer international order, Macron's advocacy for India's inclusion alongside other major players like Brazil, Germany, and Japan may serve as a catalyst for a broader transformation of the UNSC. The outcome of these discussions could shape the future of international diplomacy and cooperation, paving the way for a more inclusive framework that addresses the concerns and aspirations of a diverse global population.
Â
