A recent and deeply concerning study conducted by the Securities and Exchange Board of India (Sebi) has shed light on the challenging realities faced by retail traders operating within the Futures and Options (F&O) market. The findings of this comprehensive report reveal that over the past three financial years, specifically from FY22 to FY24, an astonishing 93% of individual traders engaged in the F&O segment have reported suffering losses, while a mere 7% have managed to achieve profitability. This stark statistic highlights the overwhelming difficulties and risks that characterize this trading environment.
To put this into perspective, the report indicates that there are approximately 1.13 crore retail traders active in the F&O markets, collectively incurring a staggering loss of Rs 1.81 lakh crore during this period. This translates to an average loss of around Rs 2 lakh per trader, factoring in transaction costs, which underscores the severe financial impact of trading in this high-stakes arena. Additionally, the report reveals that the top 3.5% of loss-makers incurred even more significant financial setbacks, averaging losses of about Rs 28 lakh each. In contrast, a mere 1% of traders managed to achieve profits exceeding Rs 1 lakh, further underscoring the high stakes and inherent risks involved in F&O trading.
Despite the pervasive narrative promoted by social media influencers and self-proclaimed financial experts, which often suggests that options trading can lead to quick and easy profits, the reality for the vast majority of retail traders tells a dramatically different story. The data presented in the study indicates that a substantial number of traders continue to engage in trading activities even after experiencing consecutive losses, revealing a potential addictive quality to derivatives trading. Remarkably, over 75% of those who reported losses continued trading despite their financial setbacks, highlighting the psychological and emotional factors that can drive traders to persist in the face of adversity.
When examining the differences between trading in futures and options, the Sebi report provides crucial insights. It was found that the percentage of loss-makers in futures contracts consistently remained lower than that of options contracts throughout the study period. For instance, in FY24, 60% of futures traders reported financial losses, whereas a staggering 91.5% of options traders ended up facing significant setbacks. This significant disparity indicates that trading in options may carry even higher risks compared to futures, emphasizing the need for careful consideration and risk management.
The rapid rise in retail participation in the F&O market has been notable, with the number of retail traders nearly doubling—from 51 lakh traders in FY22 to an impressive 96 lakh in FY24. This surge in participation has been driven by increased market awareness and the influence of online financial personalities, often referred to as "influencers." However, this influx of traders has not necessarily translated into profitable outcomes, as indicated by the alarming statistics regarding losses.
In breaking down the losses experienced by different categories of traders, the Sebi study highlights that small traders—those with a turnover of less than Rs 1 lakh crore over three years—incurred a total net loss of Rs 1,003 crore. Conversely, high-value traders, defined as those with a turnover exceeding Rs 1 crore during the same period, faced total losses amounting to Rs 1.41 lakh crore. This stark contrast illustrates how even those engaged in higher-value trading are not immune to the risks and challenges associated with the F&O market.
Moreover, the report draws attention to the significant increase in the number of options traders, which more than doubled from 42.2 lakh in FY22 to an impressive 85.7 lakh in FY24. However, intriguingly, the average size of trades has decreased from Rs 13,055 to Rs 11,824, suggesting that traders are opting for smaller transactions amid the prevailing risks associated with larger investments. This trend reflects a cautious approach among many traders who may be increasingly aware of the financial dangers they face.
An intriguing aspect of the Sebi report is its exploration of the relationship between age and trading success. The findings indicate that younger traders, particularly those under the age of 30, are more likely to experience losses, with a staggering 93% of traders in this age group reporting negative outcomes in FY24. In stark contrast, traders over the age of 60 exhibited a significantly lower loss percentage of 79%. This disparity may suggest that older traders possess better risk management skills and greater market experience, enabling them to navigate the complexities of trading more effectively than their younger counterparts.
Income levels also play a crucial role in determining a trader’s likelihood of experiencing financial losses. The study revealed that low-income traders—those earning less than Rs 5 lakh annually—were particularly vulnerable, with an alarming 92.2% suffering losses in F&O trading. As annual income increased, the percentage of loss-making traders correspondingly decreased, highlighting the financial challenges faced by lower-income individuals in engaging with such high-risk investment vehicles.
The study further identified gender disparities in trading outcomes, revealing that a higher percentage of male traders (91.9%) incurred losses in F&O trading compared to female traders (86.3%) in FY24. The average loss per female trader was reported at Rs 75,973, while male traders faced higher average losses of Rs 88,804. These differences may warrant further investigation into the factors contributing to varying trading outcomes between male and female investors, including differences in risk tolerance and trading strategies.
In light of these troubling findings, Sebi has taken proactive measures to safeguard retail investors from the pitfalls associated with F&O trading. An expert panel has recently recommended the publication of a comprehensive consultation paper outlining a seven-step guide designed to curb excessive speculation and mitigate the financial damage that can arise from engaging in high-risk trading. This initiative aims to address the pressing concerns surrounding derivatives trading, which legendary investor Warren Buffett has famously described as "financial weapons of mass destruction." By promoting informed and responsible trading practices, Sebi hopes to foster a healthier and more sustainable financial ecosystem that protects investors from the inherent risks associated with F&O markets.
Â
