The Group of Ministers (GoM) tasked with evaluating the Goods and Services Tax (GST) implications on health and life insurance premiums held a crucial meeting this past Saturday, where they discussed potential policy changes aimed at alleviating financial burdens for consumers. The GoM made a significant recommendation to exempt GST on health insurance premiums paid by individuals—excluding senior citizens—when the coverage limit is up to Rs 5 lakh. This decision is expected to provide essential financial relief to many individuals and families who depend on health insurance as a safeguard against unexpected medical expenses. However, it is important to note that an 18% GST rate will continue to apply to health insurance premiums exceeding the Rs 5 lakh threshold, which underscores a continued tax burden for those seeking higher coverage options.
In a broader context, the discussions surrounding GST rate rationalisation were an integral part of the GoM's agenda. The panel, which focuses on tax adjustments and optimisations, convened separately on the same day to explore potential revisions to tax rates on a variety of essential goods. This list includes packaged drinking water, bicycles, exercise notebooks, luxury wristwatches, and footwear. The aim of these discussions is to strike a balance between generating sufficient revenue for the government while simultaneously reducing the tax burden on essential and commonly used goods that impact the everyday lives of consumers.
The final decision regarding the GST on health and life insurance premiums, along with the proposed adjustments suggested by the GoM for other consumer goods, is expected to be deliberated and decided upon by the GST Council. This council, chaired by the Union Finance Minister, includes representatives from various states and is crucial in determining the implementation of these recommendations. A meeting of the GST Council is scheduled for next month, and it will play a pivotal role in shaping the future of GST rates and structures across the country.
An official statement from the GoM indicated that the proposed rate adjustments could lead to an estimated revenue gain of approximately Rs 22,000 crore. This projected revenue gain is essential for offsetting the potential revenue loss that may result from the lowered GST rates on insurance premiums. This balance is crucial for ensuring that the government can continue to fund essential services while implementing tax relief measures that benefit consumers.
Among the noteworthy recommendations from the GoM on GST rate rationalisation is a proposal to reduce the GST on packaged drinking water, particularly for containers of 20 liters and above, from the current rate of 18% down to a more manageable 5%. Should the GST Council accept these recommendations, consumers may also benefit from a reduction in the GST on bicycles priced under Rs 10,000, which would see their tax rate lowered from 12% to 5%. Additionally, the GoM has proposed that the GST on exercise notebooks be reduced from 12% to 5%, a move that would enhance affordability for students and their families. On the other hand, the panel also suggested increasing the GST on luxury items, such as shoes priced above Rs 15,000, from 18% to a significant 28%. Similarly, the GoM proposed hiking the GST on wristwatches costing over Rs 25,000 from 18% to 28%, reflecting a strategy to adjust tax rates based on the consumer segment these products cater to.
In comments made to reporters following the GoM meetings, Bihar Deputy Chief Minister Samrat Chaudhary, who also convenes the GoM focusing on health and life insurance premiums, expressed a strong commitment among all members to provide financial relief to the populace, particularly emphasizing the need to cater to the needs of senior citizens. Chaudhary confirmed that the group will compile its findings and recommendations into a report for submission to the GST Council, and he noted that further meetings will be held prior to finalising this report. This recent meeting marked the inaugural gathering of the 13-member GoM specifically focused on health and life insurance premiums, a group formed to assess and recommend tax rates following a previous meeting in the previous month.
The panel includes ministers from several states, including Uttar Pradesh, Rajasthan, West Bengal, Karnataka, Kerala, Andhra Pradesh, Goa, Gujarat, Meghalaya, Punjab, Tamil Nadu, and Telangana. This diverse representation reflects a collaborative effort across India to address GST-related concerns and the need for reform. The GoM has been mandated to finalise and submit its report to the GST Council by the end of October, indicating a timeline that underscores the urgency of these discussions.
In the fiscal year 2023-24, the Centre and states collectively garnered approximately Rs 8,262.94 crore in revenue through GST on health insurance premiums. Additionally, Rs 1,484.36 crore was collected specifically from GST on health reinsurance premiums. The substantial revenue generated from these taxes underscores the critical role that health and life insurance play within the GST framework and the importance of maintaining a fair and efficient taxation system that benefits both the government and the public.
The six-member GoM on GST rate rationalization includes influential finance ministers from Uttar Pradesh, Rajasthan, Karnataka, West Bengal, and Kerala. During their discussions, the GoM also explored the possibility of increasing tax rates on certain goods, such as aerated beverages and luxury items, as a means of compensating for the anticipated revenue losses associated with lowering GST rates on essential goods used by the average consumer.
Currently, the GST system operates under a four-tier tax structure featuring slabs set at 5%, 12%, 18%, and 28%. Essential goods are typically either exempted or taxed at the lowest slab, while luxury and demerit items attract the highest tax rates. Additionally, luxury and sin goods incur a cess on top of the highest 28% slab, further increasing the tax burden on such items. Notably, the average GST rate has fallen below the revenue-neutral rate of 15.3%, highlighting the need for ongoing discussions about GST rate rationalisation to ensure fiscal stability and adequate revenue generation for essential government services and initiatives. This ongoing dialogue is crucial as the government navigates the complexities of taxation in a rapidly evolving economic landscape, aiming to create a fair and effective system that supports both growth and equity.
Â
